5 Co-Employment Myths That Keep Business Owners From Using a PEO
Discover the truth about co-employment with PEOs. We debunk five common myths, explaining how they can enhance your business while retaining your control.
5 Co-Employment Myths That Keep Business Owners From Using a PEO
10:01
Updated August 2026
PRemployer | Professional Employer Organization | Dothan, Alabama
Co-employment is a contract that lets a PEO handle the paperwork of being an employer, like payroll taxes and benefits, while you keep running your business. The word worries people more than the arrangement ever should. Here are five common myths about PEO co-employment and what actually happens.
What does co-employment actually mean?
Co-employment means you and the PEO share specific employer responsibilities, spelled out in a contract. You direct the work. The PEO handles the administrative side of being an employer.
The piece that makes people nervous is also the piece that makes a PEO useful. PRemployer becomes the employer of record for tax and insurance purposes. It files your employment taxes under its own federal employer identification number, the FEIN, and issues your team’s W-2s under that number. That is what opens the door to group benefits pricing and takes payroll tax filing off your desk. It does not hand over your company.
Myth 1: Does a PEO take control of your business?
No. You keep control of hiring, firing, pay, schedules, and every day-to-day decision. Co-employment does not change that.
A PEO’s role is administrative. It remits payroll taxes on your behalf and gives your team access to its benefits plans. Who you hire, who you let go, and how you run the place stay in your hands. If a provider ever makes you feel removed from your own company, that is a problem with that provider, not with co-employment.
Myth 2: Is co-employment the same as employee leasing?
No. Employee leasing and PEO co-employment are different arrangements, and the difference comes down to who controls the work.
Employee leasing usually covers a temporary or project-based need. A staffing agency supplies the workers and directs much of what they do. In a PEO relationship, the workers are your employees. You hire them, you manage them, and you direct their work. The PEO handles the employer paperwork behind them. A lot of the fear around co-employment starts with confusing these two things.
Myth 3: Does a PEO create joint-employment liability?
No. A PEO co-employment arrangement spells out who is responsible for what, which is exactly what keeps joint-employment problems from forming.
Joint employment becomes a legal question when two businesses both exert control over a worker and neither has clearly defined its role. Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), that shared and undefined control is the issue. Employee leasing can blur the line, because the agency and your company may both be directing the same person. A PEO contract defines the split up front. You direct the work. The PEO handles payroll taxes, benefits administration, and the related filings.
Myth 4: Do you have to drop your current providers?
No, with one exception. You can keep the healthcare plan, the workers’ comp carrier, and the vendors you already like. Payroll is the one function the PEO takes over.
If your current benefits work for you and the price is right, there is no rule that says you have to move them. The one piece a PEO runs is payroll, because payroll tax filing flows through the co-employment arrangement. Processing payroll accurately and on time is what a PEO does all day, so that hand-off usually makes your week easier.
No. In most cases your employees notice better benefits and steadier paychecks. To them, you are still the employer.
What changes for your team is access. That means group health plans, retirement options, and payroll that lands correctly on the day they were told it would.
At small companies that use a PEO, 52 percent of employees at businesses with 10 to 49 people have a retirement plan, compared to 23 percent at companies that do not use one, according to NAPEO. Businesses that use a PEO also see about 12 percent lower turnover.
People tend to stay where the benefits are good and the paycheck is reliable.
Co-employment is the mechanism that makes a PEO work. The employer paperwork moves to the PEO. Your authority over your business stays exactly where it is.
More than 230,000 businesses in the United States work with a PEO, and NAPEO puts the return on investment from cost savings alone at roughly 27 percent, much of it from access to more affordable benefits. None of that is possible without the co-employment agreement doing its job quietly in the background.
Still nervous about the word co-employment?
Talk to a real person at PRemployer. We will walk you through exactly what shifts to us, what stays with you, and what it would look like for your business.
Both companies are, for different purposes. You are the worksite employer who directs the work and makes the business decisions. The PEO is the employer of record for payroll taxes and insurance, filing under its own federal employer identification number and issuing W-2s to your employees.
Does co-employment mean the PEO can fire my employees?
No. Hiring, firing, and discipline stay with you. The PEO administers the paperwork that follows those decisions, such as final pay and benefits changes, but the decisions are yours.
Is a PEO the same as a staffing agency?
No. A staffing agency supplies workers and directs a share of their work. A PEO supports the employees you already hired and manage by handling payroll, benefits, and compliance behind the scenes.
Can I leave a PEO if it is not the right fit?
Yes. A PEO relationship is a service agreement. Check your contract for notice requirements and timing, then move payroll and benefits back in-house or to another provider. A well-run transition is planned around payroll cycles and open enrollment.
Will my employees’ W-2s change under a PEO?
Your employees’ W-2s are issued under the PEO’s federal employer identification number as part of the co-employment arrangement. Their pay, their job, and your direction of their work do not change.
What does a PEO handle, and what do I keep?
The PEO handles payroll and payroll tax filing, benefits administration, workers’ comp and risk support, and HR compliance paperwork. You keep hiring and firing, pay rates, schedules, culture, and every decision about how the business runs. The split is written into your service agreement, so there is no guessing about who owns what.
Discover how southern hospitality transforms PEO partnerships, ensuring personalized service and support that goes beyond standard offerings for your...
